Want a more obedient dog? Stop yelling and try gentle training methods

Your tone of voice and volume play a significant role in your dog’s development and how you bond. Yelling at your dog can make your dog nervous and fearful.

How you communicate with your dog speaks volumes about your personality and style.

Unfortunately, just like with a child, your tone and volume play a significant role in your dog’s development and how you bond. Yelling at your dog can make your dog nervous and fearful.

Yelling can also make your dog less likely to respond to your commands, making you more frustrated and likely to yell.

New research and most dog-training experts recommend using a soft, quiet voice when you talk to your dog instead of yelling.

That doesn’t mean you have to use baby talk. It doesn’t mean you can’t be firm or discipline your dog.

It just means stop yelling at your dog.

Here are seven reasons why yelling at your dog is detrimental.

1. Yelling stresses dogs 

Multiple training strategies can be grouped into two general approaches: aversive-based and reward-based.

Yelling at your dog does not provide positive reinforcement. Scientists studied stress behavior and cortisol levels in dogs’ saliva to determine the most effective strategy for managing stress.

When their owners yelled, the dogs’ behavior showed signs of stress, such as yawning and a higher cortisol level.

2. Yelling affects training

Another reason to stop yelling is that it affects how your dog responds to your commands.

If you constantly yell, your dog doesn’t understand what is essential.

Dogs hear better than humans, and yelling or repeating yourself works against you. After a while, your dog will start to ignore your commands.

Train your dog like CIA agents do, and teach her to respond to commands when you use a conversational tone.

Doing this will make obedience training sessions more productive and reduce behavior problems.

3. Yelling is confusing 

Most dogs understand only a few words. Dogs pay more attention to the tone and pitch of your voice.

Yelling at your dog can confuse her and make her hyper or aggressive as she tries to imitate your actions.

A classic example is when you yell at your dog to stop barking. The dog focuses on the fact that you are yelling rather than the words you say.

The dog thinks you are barking, too, and will likely only bark louder.

4. Yelling prevents an emergency response

If you constantly shout at your dog, your dog doesn’t know when something is essential.

If you talk calmly, your dog is more likely to respond when you raise your voice or give a short, simple stop command. This will also likely capture your dog’s attention and encourage positive behavior.

For example, if your dog gets out of your yard and wanders toward the street, she’s more likely to respond if you yell, “Wait or stop,” rather than walking into the street.

5. Yelling affects your image as the leader

Dogs are social creatures. They are eager to accept you as the leader but expect specific behavior.

If you are yelling or, worse, abusive toward your dog, you won’t establish the trust and respect you need.

Leaders must know that being aggressive and trying to scare others does not earn trust or respect.

6. Yelling encourages bad behavior

Constant yelling will create a pattern of negative reinforcement.

For instance, when you call your dog, and it takes a long time for her to respond and come back to you, do not respond by yelling at her again.

That shows your dog she has no incentive to come back.

Instead, call your dog, and when she comes back, praise her and give her a treat.

Why would your dog want to please you if all you do is yell?

7. Yelling inhibits learning

Dog owners should understand that dogs do not speak human, and angry tirades won’t convince the dog that she behaved badly.

She also does not connect your anger to what she did hours ago.

Make your tone a distinguishing factor to make sure the message to your dog is clear rather than confusing.

Teach your dog what you want by speaking calmly and giving rewards.

This helps your dog understand the link between your command and the desired actions.

Stop yelling

Changing from yelling to a softer tone may take time and practice, but it’s a rewarding change for you and your dog.

Here are some tips to help you transition effectively:

Become aware of your tone

Before changing your tone, you need to recognize when you’re raising your voice. Pay attention to your reactions and how you communicate with your dog.

Start by noting situations that trigger yelling and consider alternative responses.

Practice breathing techniques

When you feel frustrated, take a deep breath to center yourself before reacting.

Inhale deeply and exhale slowly to help calm your nerves and control your tone.

Use a calm voice

Incorporate training exercises that focus on commands in a calm, soothing voice.

This reinforces the idea that communication doesn’t have to come from a place of stress. Start with basic commands like “sit” or “stay” using a quiet tone and reward your dog for responding positively.

Establish a routine

Create a consistent routine for training or interaction moments. Setting training times can help you and your dog know what to expect and minimize stress, making it easier to speak softly.

Use positive reinforcement for yourself

As you would reward your dog for good behavior, credit yourself for using a softer tone.

Celebrate small victories when you communicate without yelling, reinforcing your progress.

Use visual or physical cues

Sometimes, non-verbal communication can be just as effective. Pair your commands with hand signals or gestures that your dog can understand, which can help minimize the need for speaking.

Set realistic expectations

Understand that transitioning takes time. Be patient with yourself and your dog; don’t expect changes to happen overnight.

Recognize that mistakes will happen, but each effort to speak softly is a step in the right direction.

Engage in bonding activities

Spend quality time with your dog, engaging in playful activities. This strengthens your bond and creates positive associations, making communicating softly when directing behavior easier.

Remind yourself of the goal

Keep in mind the benefits of transitioning to a softer tone. Visualize your dog responding happily and confidently, creating a stronger, more trusting relationship.

Try other training methods

Training dogs can be a rewarding experience, and it’s possible to communicate effectively without resorting to yelling at your dog or negative reinforcement.

Some alternative training methods and techniques emphasize positive interactions and reward-based strategies:

Positive reinforcement training

Using positive dog training techniques is a foundational method in dog training that rewards desired behaviors. This can include treats, praise, or playtime whenever a dog exhibits the behavior you want to encourage.

For example, if you want your dog to sit, you can reward it with a treat immediately after it does so. This strengthens the association between the command and the behavior, making your dog more likely to repeat it.

Clicker training

Clicker training is a highly effective form of positive reinforcement that uses a distinct sound (the clicker) to mark a desired behavior when it occurs.

The click cues that the dog has done something right, followed by a reward.

This method helps establish a clear communication channel between the trainer and the dog, making it easier for them to understand what you expect from them.

For example, you can click and treat when your dog sits on command, reinforcing that behavior more effectively.

Reward-based methods

In addition to treats, you can use other rewards, such as toys, affection, or attention.

Understanding what motivates your dog is key to successful training.

For some dogs, a favorite toy might be more rewarding than food.

Incorporating a variety of rewards can also help keep training sessions engaging and motivating.

Target training

Target training involves teaching your dog to touch or follow a specific object or your hand to achieve a desired behavior.

By guiding your dog to the target, you can encourage them to perform behaviors like sitting, staying, or coming when called.

It’s a fun and interactive way to engage with your dog while effectively communicating commands.

Relationship-based training

This method focuses on building a strong bond between you and your dog.

By understanding your dog’s body language and behavior, you can tailor your training approach to better suit their needs.

Engaging in regular playtime, exercise, and socialization can foster trust and willingness to learn, creating a cooperative spirit during training sessions.

Clickerless training

If you don’t have a clicker handy, you can still practice the principles of clicker training by using a verbal marker (like “yes” or “ok”) followed by a reward.

This method immediately reinforces good behavior without needing any special tools.

Seek professional help if needed

If you find it challenging to change your habits, consider hiring a professional dog trainer or behaviorist.

They can provide personalized strategies to help you improve your communication with your puppy.

Stay calm for successful training

A calm, soft tone and positive training methods can create a nurturing and effective learning environment.

Here are some specific situations where these methods shine:

Basic commands

When teaching dogs commands like “sit” or “stay,” a gentle tone helps reduce anxiety and build trust.

For example, when a dog successfully sits on command, a trainer can softly praise it with phrases like “Good job, buddy!” and a treat. This positive reinforcement encourages the dog to repeat the behavior without fear of reprimand.

Socialization

A calm voice can help the dog and the trainer relax during socialization exercises with other dogs or people.

When introducing a shy dog to new environments or other dogs, speaking softly reassures the dog.

Using treats to reward calm behavior reinforces the idea that social interactions are positive experiences.

Leash training

Many dogs pull while on a leash, frustrating the dog and the handler.

When the dog pulls, a trainer can redirect it back to the correct position using a soft voice instead of harsh tones.

When the dog walks beside them, praising with a gentle tone and a treat reinforces the desired behavior, making walks more enjoyable.

Dealing with fear or anxiety

For dogs fearful of loud noises or new experiences, a calm and soothing tone helps them feel secure.

For instance, if a dog is scared of thunder, speaking softly while offering a treat or engaging in a favorite activity can create a positive association, helping the dog cope better.

Potty training

When a dog has an accident indoors, responding calmly rather than scolding prevents fear or anxiety about bathroom habits.

Guiding the dog outside and praising them when they go in the right spot positively reinforces good behavior.

Trick training

When teaching tricks like “roll over” or “shake,” an upbeat tone encourages enthusiasm without overwhelming the dog.

Positive reinforcement through treats or affection when the dog performs the trick successfully reinforces their willingness to learn and engage in the training process.

Speak softly, calmly 

Training can be frustrating. When it becomes overwhelming, stop and take a break.

Dogs are sensitive and emotional. They sense even the most subtle tone and body language changes. 

Communicate with your dog softly and calmly to build a strong bond. 

That will help keep your pup a happy dog.

Pay attention to body language

Body language plays a crucial role in how your dog perceives you.

When communicating with your dog, maintain an open, relaxed posture. 

Avoid crossing your arms or making sudden movements to keep your dog from feeling anxious or intimidated. 

Keep your shoulders relaxed and stand tall. Avoid towering over your dog.

Use positive reinforcement

Positive reinforcement is crucial to successful communication with your dog. 

Instead of yelling or scolding your dog when she misbehaves, use positive reinforcement techniques such as treats or praise to encourage good behavior. 

Speak slowly and softly

When speaking to your dog, remember they may not understand every word but do recognize the tone of your voice. 

Speaking slowly in a calm and soothing tone conveys a sense of reassurance and comfort. 

Shouting or speaking too quickly can seem aggressive or intimidating, which may scare or confuse your dog.

Avoid punishment

Punishing your dog by yelling or physically reprimanding them can negatively affect their behavior and mental well-being.

It can lead to fear-based behaviors such as hiding, cowering, or aggression toward you or others. 

Instead of punishment, focus on rewarding good behavior while calmly redirecting undesirable actions.

Match your tone to your words

Ensure that your tone matches your words when talking to your dog. 

Using a calm and soft tone while commanding your dog to do something will convey a sense of authority and confidence, making your dog more likely to obey.

Similarly, praising your dog with an excited or high-pitched tone makes her feel appreciated and motivated.

Final thoughts on yelling at your dog

Speaking calmly and assertively when teaching commands to your dog is better than always shouting at them.

Reward-based methods are always more productive than aversive-based methods.

The bottom line is your dog wants to please you.

Before you yell, consider if something you did incorrectly provoked your dog’s behavior.

Do not punish your pet for your mistakes. Learn how to work together so you’ll both be happy.

Elizabeth Skinner always loved animals and started a career as a police dog trainer while studying at a college. She decided to buy custom research papers sometimes, as the help of experts allowed her to dedicate more time to her true calling in life.

Master dog training: 30 expert tips for a perfectly behaved pup